CMS Care Compare · 2026 4 nursing homes Indiana

Fayette County, Indiana

Verify with CMS →

County inventory for Fayette County, Indiana is drawn from U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Nursing Home Compare / Home Health Compare (14,710 Medicare-certified nursing homes nationwide) with cost context from the private CareScout 2025 Cost of Care Survey - see our methodology. CMS star-quality signature

Rated homes in Fayette County average 4.3 CMS stars (upper tercile, >3.46) across 4 nursing homes - 297 licensed beds, CareScout 2025 Indiana medians.

Indiana overview → About this data

County care plate

Sheet IN-FAYETTE-INDIANA · Fayette, IN

NH-SMALL · BEDS-SMALL · STAR-HIGH · HH-NONE · RANK-MID · PHOTO-NONE · AL-MID · BOOK-FULL

  • NH-SMALL 4 homes
  • BEDS-SMALL 297 beds
  • STAR-HIGH 4.3★ avg
  • HH-NONE 0 agencies
  • RANK-MID #839/2,851
  • PHOTO-NONE No peer
  • AL-MID $5,639/mo
  • BOOK-FULL 4/4 NH · 0 HH

Stamps lead with CMS star-quality tercile (high) plus nursing-home inventory, licensed beds, Home Health Compare agencies, corpus NH-count rank, photo-finish peer, and CareScout assisted-living medians.

What stronger CMS stars show for Fayette County

CMS star quality is the standout for Fayette County: rated homes average 4.3/5 (upper tercile, >3.46) across 4 nursing homes and 297 licensed beds.

CareScout 2025 Indiana medians frame mid-pack counties like this: assisted living $5,639/mo, semi-private nursing $8,943/mo, private nursing $10,326/mo, home health aide $6,673/mo, adult day $2,752/mo. Local Fayette County providers may sit above or below those state medians.

Star counts skew stronger here (1 at 2★, 3 at 5★). Ownership leans For profit - Corporation (75% of 4 homes). Named 4★+ examples include Caroleton Healthcare Center, Heritage House Rehabilitation & Health Care Center, Hickory Creek at Connersville. Still weigh inspection history, staffing, bed size, and specialty units (dementia, rehab, ventilator) before visiting.

1★
0
2★
1
3★
0
4★
0
5★
3

Sources: CMS Nursing Home Compare + CareScout 2025 Cost of Care Survey. See methodology.

$5,639
Assisted Living / mo
$8,943
Nursing (Semi) / mo
$6,673
Home Care / mo
4.3
Avg CMS Rating

Top facilities in Fayette, IN

Ranked by CMS overall star rating, not an editorial "best of" pick. Visit in person and consult a care professional before choosing.

  1. 1
    Caroleton Healthcare Center
    5★
  2. 2
    Heritage House Rehabilitation & Health Care Center
    5★
  3. 3
    Hickory Creek at Connersville
    5★
  4. 4
    Majestic Care of Connersville
    2★

Nursing Homes in Fayette County

4 CMS-certified homes in this county book, ordered by overall star rating.

Facility City Rating Beds Ownership
Caroleton Healthcare Center Connersville 5/5 50 For profit - Corporation
Heritage House Rehabilitation & Health Care Center Connersville 5/5 98 Government - County
Hickory Creek at Connersville Connersville 5/5 36 For profit - Corporation
Majestic Care of Connersville Connersville 2/5 113 For profit - Corporation

Read next for stronger-star Fayette

Decode Five-Star for Fayette County homes
Mid-pack context for Fayette: What a county-average CMS overall rating does — and does not — tell a family.
Choosing among 4 Fayette County homes
Higher-star neighbourhood: A visit checklist that starts from CMS stars, then adds staffing, ownership, and specialty units.
Nursing home vs assisted living near Fayette
Sparse home-health path: Care-level and cost differences before you shortlist a CMS-certified facility.
Cost calculator for Fayette County planning
Sparse home-health path: State CareScout medians rolled into a monthly planning estimate.

Continue on the Indiana elder-care overview or the highest-rated states ranking. Costs shown are Indiana state-level medians from CareScout 2025 (county-level cost data is not available).

Read our methodology - how CMS Care Compare and CareScout 2025 are joined for Fayette County.